這次的測試主題 是我很早很早以前就想做的
那就是生產終了後 身價水漲船高的貴公子 Nikkor AF 28mm/f1.4 D 對決
副廠唯一同焦段大眼睛 Sigma AF 28mm/f1.8 EX DG Asph. Macro
01. 主角登場
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-3f8b036ee3fa7f94a8ccf1b92c84c098.jpg)
02. 加上遮光罩的英姿
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-0e9ccf09d592e405748d950d2bcb29b2.jpg)
兩者目前二手價格相差可能高達有八倍之多
然而光圈只相差不到一級
Sigma 28/1.8 以 1/8 的價格是否有可能以小博大而和貴公子平起平坐
Nikkor 28/1.4D 又有哪些優勢來穩坐 N 家廣角大光圈定焦鏡的王座呢...
首先這裡要感謝 鏡頭群實力深不可測的 Y 君再次大力相助 N 28/1.4D 乙顆!!
－－－－－－－－－－－－－－ 分隔線 －－－－－－－－－－－－－－－
本次測試分別使用了 FF (Canon 5D) 及 APS (Nikon D1X) size感光元件的機身
先上場的是 FF 全片幅的測試
機身 Canon 5D, 日間使用固定白平衡(sunny), 夜間改為自動白平衡
Test I: 焦外成像
Nikkor AF 28/1.4D (on 5D)
f1.4
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-2c0016ea345077883d6b3c88f160cb57.jpg)
f1.8
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-1275b9e0cb170d9ddbc61e549c15eed5.jpg)
f2.0
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-552dfea70beff03151d7c4d290c7f179.jpg)
f2.8
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-0874eebd467127b40c2711c0bc2d743d.jpg)
f4.0
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-b37c9ca5b5a586e96b02912f6803cab8.jpg)
f5.6
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-9a1eaa13c954cdfbb695da6bd090f86d.jpg)
f8.0
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-0ce69c030d7d34893aa3211b42586e31.jpg)
Sigma AF 28/1.8 EX DG (on 5D)
f1.8
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-b8444141f0e225a2ecbb44969e67a16e.jpg)
f2.0
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-12d6f64d8e126a920d121eb2a5d97365.jpg)
f2.8
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-6ba888f91df3eed0d6990988f1bc298a.jpg)
f4.0
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-b93e420a26e99efb25afc62255989e86.jpg)
f5.6
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-30cccee8a873c3e3fb7d8eb8b9591d38.jpg)
f8.0
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-edc9afb4933b1a0dd4ce3cabb1bd97c1.jpg)
Test II: 焦外成像
Nikkor AF 28/1.4D (on 5D)
f1.4
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-a93619d5d21c9b921c6f558b054a65cf.jpg)
f1.8
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-bad2c59ff92d64ab4fd39bfab89e21aa.jpg)
f2.0
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-c09da2f1cdc80936bda77b3f03552d86.jpg)
f2.8
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-27ac12a1865dfb5ddf813766ec6bf8d2.jpg)
f4.0
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-a3ce2196b86ee215f5c03f67a78c5ab2.jpg)
f5.6
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-02905341a4c88ce390c77a52f98a95d9.jpg)
f8.0
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-a2abd794cfbc6117b8d247e509351cea.jpg)
Sigma AF 28/1.8 EX DG (on 5D)
f1.8
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-18d2ec3e5117661fdee012d61ff6bd5c.jpg)
f2.0
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-31cbb9667847a6ee45812710b34a4e32.jpg)
f2.8
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-f1c5b111e399515fc116976d3e6c9d9c.jpg)
f4.0
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-525ebe983e0421ff75795cd7e1fc0126.jpg)
f5.6
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-4b863467bf088da7402b43f929d3f2e7.jpg)
f8.0
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-8535a102046c7f25a570c9f538504f33.jpg)
Test III: 焦外成像
Nikkor AF 28/1.4D (on 5D)
f1.4
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-a7074fd62e0b3ed231e7608c00af3009.jpg)
f1.8
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-f53ceca381ab17c283a6fd5cba170183.jpg)
f2.0
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-8f5837445d8e5ffae53ab438bb7f72e8.jpg)
f2.8
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-bb2f9860a23b4119016e55a24cf1b29c.jpg)
f4.0
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-961bf9721e50e3ae5e86fcf064a4931f.jpg)
f5.6
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-b179d084cd87cd2111fe1d88685a9535.jpg)
f8.0
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-0ca2dc2dbc3dc888993065f91d1dbe87.jpg)
Sigma AF 28/1.8 EX DG (on 5D)
f1.8
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-9c647464406f1c4adb176995537148ce.jpg)
f2.0
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-ce3da9934269146f9ccaff6aae994556.jpg)
f2.8
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-686f98a738d8a73d4d38d9ae07da3666.jpg)
f4.0
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-055729568ba88b62b94dbbeef0b07f54.jpg)
f5.6
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-4144ca16f981f651e107511dda24818f.jpg)
f8.0
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-f0abf284497e45f77caf4cd4e9d799af.jpg)
Test IV: 中央及外圍畫質
Nikkor AF 28/1.4D (on 5D)
f1.4
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-2cdf08f5e5b6512a3940ec12780872ba.jpg)
f1.4 中央
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-0267c3fbf2a1958a7e1a4bfdb3f31fa6.jpg)
f1.4 外圍
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-20e13a17ac1295a8f1a881d72f16023b.jpg)
f1.8
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-41a0c108d4b92182a0b5958b46023a3e.jpg)
f1.8 中央
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-0cd5569210a8b1f913b21d5544ea42cb.jpg)
f1.8 外圍
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-b50e576cd6d2b06b11c0b4b6a88abc2d.jpg)
f2.0
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-c3e349c0bb07ac32b4aeeec8bacefc95.jpg)
f2.0 中央
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-d8169d214ee0086dc527403cd4a0f2ee.jpg)
f2.0 外圍
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-1ceaf41371587880ea6bee96fed1fce3.jpg)
f2.8
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-55357082c1b63bc8ee63b400d45c88e1.jpg)
f2.8 中央
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-6bbeb41f4443c4d722b12d9f5a084305.jpg)
f2.8 外圍
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-63ed1fe73a104f96db91fb9be1e25704.jpg)
f4.0
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-3fe85eecf65846f90f44b480a819068e.jpg)
f4.0 中央
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-dba65ed399822eeae11fda39a58d5c47.jpg)
f4.0 外圍
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-575f20dbe8c66a87b65251431e6559b8.jpg)
f5.6
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-bf8eeba6a7c6b160abf9e7d12e42ebdb.jpg)
f5.6 中央
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-e0a8c085c1658b67bc54057f5a1688ac.jpg)
f5.6 外圍
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-8503ec4c9130468eee4e59e41b4000e6.jpg)
f8.0
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-7ef5ab49a8a6116ca7ef491b363ec3e7.jpg)
f8.0 中央
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-ab3e36123e8d60fbea1308abd48df411.jpg)
f8.0 外圍
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-58a5d6d9d08a7e3b97f4234e24406102.jpg)
Sigma AF 28/1.8 EX DG (on 5D)
f1.8
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-47c701c35d2c30a45d73c3781d466ddc.jpg)
f1.8 中央
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-e35de77fb032d435e627f1e54a9dccb9.jpg)
f1.8 外圍
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-e7778c71f7cc8d40ffe0be9bc1c3eb55.jpg)
f2.0
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-a7707e7157a6cab7adf38e6e506224a4.jpg)
f2.0 中央
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-b90d23e81ec2e5e9c4b17ddbd6a1218a.jpg)
f2.0 外圍
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-f166b0565405b9e638ef6f96da3af709.jpg)
f2.8
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-a6a9287b5edcc9df60ba669696bc2d36.jpg)
f2.8 中央
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-5a092a97bc90f3cdd70438b0e78483a9.jpg)
f2.8 外圍
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-7c662603eaab5cc438d3c9197d124a9c.jpg)
f4.0
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-f593832daa9b621bae58f03b3d83f39d.jpg)
f4.0 中央
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-01c9fed20ce6e72caaafce6763e42912.jpg)
f4.0 外圍
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-271f2f256da53b8f759f2a04334fdfbe.jpg)
f5.6
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-47cbc9831c5a219208ab00235517d8a4.jpg)
f5.6 中央
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-5ace48a7d461c5bbe19bd8af4618c62f.jpg)
f5.6 外圍
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-691c79dd2fe392b2ebcce3e189907b32.jpg)
f8.0
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-b612bf465d0254832c760613c6610c01.jpg)
f8.0 中央
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-8d8f20c47f5c0a6c9f9c461174cab355.jpg)
f8.0 外圍
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-b54113db513c1dcbc1c1a8848bde7006.jpg)
Test V: (夜間)光點形狀/邊緣畫質
(下面的照片如果沒有說明，您分的出是哪顆拍的嗎)
Nikkor AF 28/1.4D (on 5D)
f1.4
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-8adfd211bb9c58ff3bd1d6143a24662e.jpg)
f1.4 邊緣裁切
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-997116a801acbe2c5581b4b00a1666da.jpg)
f1.8
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-3e60f7e4dd4fe70ccb402163199c2f3e.jpg)
f2.0
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-b1e860d7e25a46aa0c459add0224b498.jpg)
f2.8
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-9a15994d411f55f1a220f702cbe32fd2.jpg)
f4.0
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-0cd4156969adf0d0879123deed051117.jpg)
Sigma AF 28/1.8 EX DG (on 5D)
f1.8
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-ac795691063f95e06741eb9351b48a8e.jpg)
f1.8 邊緣
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-21de95a4967892f413b693dce7242a8b.jpg)
f2.0
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-cbc9ce88ae0880a2e51839bbc5259caf.jpg)
f2.8
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-b8e5d3e7bbbd55f0cb32b8801eced02b.jpg)
f4.0
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-b758de1ead70c298282dbd70dad3c394.jpg)
Test VI: (夜間)中央畫質
(下面的照片如果沒有說明，您分的出是哪顆拍的嗎)
Nikkor AF 28/1.4D (on 5D)
f1.4
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-cd4c4e43b726a89fc6786a3e7bca8c5c.jpg)
f1.4 中央裁切
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-7053ba65b22e826d727e2590999cd477.jpg)
Sigma AF 28/1.8 EX DG (on 5D)
f1.8
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-79809fef648d2c45976cbefdca292f66.jpg)
f1.8 中央裁切
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-0457cf5b44f8da77d5b9e7f4ffc9bfa7.jpg)
VII: 測試中隨手拍
後面的照片是用這顆鏡頭拍的
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-656aa530c03caf7a778d41673a426589.jpg)
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-275347398d61fca3369be298b8a71e0b.jpg)
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-6842be60d9284471daaeaaa9a361c6ee.jpg)
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-0085b2a602b53d43674167a2bd8808ef.jpg)
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-ed6464a17bac6e67b4a92a5c5e89917f.jpg)
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-2ba2697adbd46d36cb58d8d262c4e51d.jpg)
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-08529e94686d4f02a80a02a760673884.jpg)
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-d99884502e6d8a2091dd7412061316ba.jpg)
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-0f375e29d74fa4b47aaae14b60ba63e8.jpg)
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-173cf4c0c946da0662947e0b7afd54cb.jpg)
下面這張照片是用這顆鏡頭拍的
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-f6350bf188a62e71d421f0d74516a921.jpg)
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-278ca5792f3df3f6e5dda23753f0c9e2.jpg)
－－－－－－－－－－－－－－－－－ 分隔線 －－－－－－－－－－－－－－－－
老實說我不相信會有人把上面的照片全都仔細看完，哈哈~~
不過能看到這裡也實在算你厲害...
接下來的是 APS size 的測試
機身 Nikon D1X, 日間使用固定白平衡(sunny), 夜間改為自動白平衡
Test I: 焦外成像
Nikkor AF 28/1.4D (on D1X)
f1.4
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-8a87178c824b23335b8c53baa7abcb89.jpg)
f1.8
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-2ce291c742f09d03172343eef6437678.jpg)
f2.0
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-4409ac0caab55e40b978ea9da863c122.jpg)
f2.8
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-6ac8789e10b90c92e681e16472d9b93d.jpg)
f4.0
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-ef82353a757777266e8a75837cedc865.jpg)
f5.6
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-33572eca6b295d1daefd5eb0b67d6bf0.jpg)
Sigma AF 28/1.8 EX DG (on D1X)
f1.8
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-a74741e27ffc6cfda52e2b3905a7a400.jpg)
f2.0
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-1bca64ae1d25cdaed6b2cc670aadcf95.jpg)
f2.8
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-389e3ea08e1ad575715d3c3971e97c05.jpg)
f4.0
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-ae2e403fa406e1d17ad5c63eaf633fa1.jpg)
f5.6
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-676498b3c013ae265b14fa691793f17e.jpg)
Test II: 焦外成像
(很遺憾的是本項測試由於合焦距離有誤差，照片僅供參考)
Nikkor AF 28/1.4D (on D1X)
f1.4
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-6eecaab79e31f6d4ab5eb5cf080061c3.jpg)
f1.8
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-b842e6fbc4cdbf28529e16c768c1b0ad.jpg)
f2.0
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-9db8ac318c74e4ca459444c8fcc227c1.jpg)
f2.8
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-831de304a4b943882ad0bd736dcafec6.jpg)
f4.0
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-f1adacab3a702a77d37ef5c39e935be6.jpg)
f5.6
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-8e8585cdb5039bad9b8dc0f2862cbac9.jpg)
Sigma AF 28/1.8 EX DG (on D1X)
(合焦點比上面的測試稍稍後移約4cm)
f1.8
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-ec35ca2dedcc85c631b35654a7d17265.jpg)
f2.0
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-2bafc9e2ef166ac88d69c1e3face0348.jpg)
f2.8
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-11e282808faf5ecf0b263d2a5aa48e0a.jpg)
f4.0
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-15cfda83329063952863821f135cf803.jpg)
f5.6
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-ce9aae874a1440d6405f3d62a69a323f.jpg)
Test III: 逆光拍攝 (保護鏡等皆已拆下)
Nikkor AF 28/1.4D (on D1X)
f1.4
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-42cbe4b96f083a1454c55044f636f1db.jpg)
f1.8
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-92f9074bedfc22f1aa4e2e56b2bed3a8.jpg)
f2.0
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-ae9aa3125c4201d8ceeedd054d816bcf.jpg)
f2.8
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-be0c5bd50cf0d22c0e12c8951f56f98d.jpg)
f4.0
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-56ec07cf11d66bb2c72f6982af35c127.jpg)
Sigma AF 28/1.8 EX DG (on D1X)
f1.8
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-182801ee9304e741ddd3e3e3ceca33e1.jpg)
f2.0
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-71a52555b1f7df2367dd8b28613728b0.jpg)
f2.8
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-ba087f0e77a5352c5ed8e142485e92f5.jpg)
f4.0
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-cd8281a2f22f97959be00a765d56a764.jpg)
f5.6
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-6afa19d4550459febd5048925883c999.jpg)
Test IV: 焦外成像
Nikkor AF 28/1.4D (on D1X)
f1.4
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-3d5a79ec02c17cf1c9212903433b7b18.jpg)
f1.8
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-b00529ea9bc290e6c509ed73edc49dcd.jpg)
f2.0
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-ca388938d2e740073efed0fae9f51362.jpg)
f2.8
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-1584bfab267ccb887730762f8e875a21.jpg)
f4.0
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-9eb7926af168f9221455a398512d4ccc.jpg)
f5.6
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-f48eacfa91eb7fe6251ab7cff81ec8e0.jpg)
Sigma AF 28/1.8 EX DG (on D1X)
f1.8
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-fd8c8438247e88a8d55dfc3f57b9c0d0.jpg)
f2.0
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-b7b8436ca4a3a884e9add089c153e04b.jpg)
f2.8
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-b328089efdc88ebcb65b55a4308c9d1b.jpg)
f4.0
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-0568942ff55ebf3d8bbdfa222b5d499e.jpg)
f5.6
![[測試]賭上尊嚴的貴公子之戰(Nikkor 28/1.4D vs Sigma 28/1.8)](http://attach.mobile01.com/attach/200803/mobile01-4cbdbbe2b8e3312b394724d836a6dc63.jpg)
恭喜您把140多張照片全部看完了!!
看完以上的照片
和你之前的觀念是不謀而合還是有些落差呢?
總括這次的測試，Sigma 28/1.8 雖然身為副廠鏡
但中央部分的畫質卻也不含糊
大多數的場合幾乎能和原廠鏡分庭抗禮
不過畫面外圍的部分就馬上露出罩門
但好在這外圍的影像是落在APS size感光元件之外
對佔大多數的APS用戶而言
算是一個利多的好消息~~
不過話說回來，在APS的機身上
相同構圖下距離要比用FF機身的遠不少
這對廣角鏡而言
用錢換來的大光圈優勢馬上又被吃掉一大半...
至於花6~8倍的價錢購入原廠Nikkor是不是值得
這裡頭有太多理性與非理性的因素存在
小弟在這裡也不敢造次發表意見
不過廣角鏡在使用上難度還是比較高一些
如果有相同的預算的話
我還是比較建議先買 58/1.2 noct. 啊哈哈~~
